We stayed for a week at the end of the summer. The house was lovely - very new and clean and spacious. The pool was also extremely nice and the spa worked well too. It's a nice location where you can walk to a (very small) beach at the end of the street and also to ice cream and a couple small restaurants. The only negative is the layout of the property. The pool is across the driveway from the front of the house (hard to watch kids unless you are across the yard actually in the pool area) and the gas grill is out in a very small back yard area off by itself. So, when you are cooking, you're isolated from everyone else. The check-in and check-out process was GREAT. Among the best I've encountered.
It was VERY unsatisfying how we were treated by Martha Murray rentals after our stay. We were given an offer to reserve the "Same week" for next year. I immediately (the day after our stay) responded to this offer and said "Yes, we'd like it." They emailed back and said "That week is already booked. Would you like a different week?" So, I checked the calendar, and there was only one week available in August next year, and the rate was a 50% increase (!!!!) versus what we paid this year. I emailed Martha Murray back to confirm that. No response whatsoever. Clearly, since the house is basically booked up for 2016 already, they don't care about me anymore. Such a bummer after a truly great house and rental process.